Candy Bar Diaper Game: How to Play, 10 Candy Bars to Use and a Free Printable
In the candy bar diaper game (also called the dirty diaper game or “guess the sweet mess”), you melt a different candy bar into each of several numbered diapers. Guests look, sniff and, if you allow it, taste, then write which candy bar they think is in each diaper. Whoever gets the most right wins. This guide covers setup, which bars to pick and how to score, plus a free PDF with a guest sheet for 10 diapers and a host answer key. The PDF downloads directly, and you don’t need to give an email.

What’s in the free PDF
- Guest sheet. Ten numbered lines, one per diaper, with space for a name at the top. Print one per guest.
- Host answer key. A matching sheet where you write which candy bar went into each numbered diaper while you set up. You read the answers from it at the end.
Using fewer than 10 diapers? Tell guests to skip the extra lines. Everything prints on plain US Letter paper and reads fine in black and white.
What you need
- 6 to 10 diapers (the cheapest pack in newborn or size 1 is fine)
- 6 to 10 different candy bars, one per diaper (fun-size bars are plenty)
- A microwave-safe bowl and a spoon, or just a butter knife if you skip melting
- A marker to number the diapers
- The printed guest sheets, one per guest, and pens
- A tray or table to line the diapers up on
- A small prize for the winner
How to play, in 5 steps
- Ask the mom-to-be first. The Emily Post Institute says the most important thing with shower games is to “check with the parent(s) to be that these games would be welcome”. This one matters more than most, because not everyone enjoys it (more on that below).
- Number the diapers and fill in the answer key. Write 1, 2, 3… on the front of each diaper. Before any chocolate goes in, write the candy bar for each number on the host answer key. As Pampers says: “jot it down so you don’t forget which diaper contains which candy!”
- Make the “mess.” Do one bar at a time. Either melt it in a microwave-safe bowl, a few seconds at a time and stirring in between, or simply squash it with a knife at room temperature. Spread it in the middle of its diaper. Melt in the bowl, not inside the diaper, and let the chocolate cool before guests come near it.
- Let guests guess. Line the diapers up in order on a tray. Guests walk past, look, sniff and write their guess next to each number. Decide in advance whether tasting is allowed (see the no-taste version below).
- Read the answers and score. Read the key out loud, number by number. Guests mark their own sheets or swap with a neighbor. Most correct answers wins.
10 candy bars that work well
The game works when each diaper has a clue guests can spot: nuts, a wafer, coconut, crisped rice, peanut butter. Pick bars that look and smell different from each other, and add one “tricky pair” if your crowd likes a challenge.
| # | Candy bar | What gives it away |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hershey’s Milk Chocolate | Plain chocolate, no filling |
| 2 | Snickers | Whole peanuts and caramel |
| 3 | Kit Kat | Bits of wafer |
| 4 | Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups | Strong peanut butter smell |
| 5 | Almond Joy | Coconut plus pieces of almond |
| 6 | Mounds | Coconut with dark chocolate, no nuts |
| 7 | Twix | Cookie crumbs and caramel |
| 8 | Crunch | Crisped rice |
| 9 | Milky Way | Nougat and caramel |
| 10 | 3 Musketeers | A light, fluffy center |
Two pairs are tricky. Almond Joy and Mounds are both coconut bars. Hershey’s describes Mounds as dark chocolate with no nuts, while Almond Joy has an almond, so the nut is the clue. The other pair is Milky Way and 3 Musketeers. For a mixed crowd that just wants to laugh, leave the pairs out and keep the bars very different.
Recipes change from time to time, so check each wrapper when you buy.
How to score (and break a tie)
The simplest rule: 1 point per correct candy bar, most points wins.
If you want guesses like “something with coconut” to count for something, use a two-level score like the one LoveToKnow suggests: 1 point for a correct description and 2 points for the exact candy bar.
Tie? Keep one extra diaper aside with a bar you didn’t use elsewhere. The tied guests get one guess each; first right answer wins. If nobody gets it, the closest description wins.
A no-taste version (and why to have one)
Not every guest will enjoy this game. In an r/BabyBumps thread, the person planning a shower said they’re not a fan of “smell the nappy” games, and another user who did play it at hers called it “pretty gross.” These are individual opinions, but they’re a good reason to plan a gentler version.
- Look and sniff only. Nobody tastes anything. It’s still a fair game, because the clues (wafer, nuts, coconut, crisped rice) are visible.
- Tasting from a plate, not the diaper. If you do allow tasting, put a little of each melted bar on a small numbered plate next to its diaper, with spoons or toothpicks. Nobody dips into the diaper itself.
- Make it optional. Guests who’d rather sit it out can be the ones reading the answers or handing out the prize.
About allergies. Several candy bars contain peanuts, tree nuts, milk, soy or wheat, which are all on the FDA’s list of major food allergens. The FDA’s advice is to “Always read food labels”: check the ingredient list and any “Contains” line on each wrapper (the FDA says allergens can be listed in either place), and tell guests which diapers have nuts before anyone tastes. If a guest has a food allergy, the look-and-sniff version means nobody has to eat anything to play. Ask them what they’re comfortable with, and keep the nut bars apart or leave them out.
Two variations
- Mash-up diapers. For a harder round, mix two or three very different bars in one diaper. LoveToKnow suggests 1 point for each candy you identify and 5 points if you name all of them.
- Candy name match (no diapers at all). Guests match baby-related words or phrases to candy bar names. It’s a paper-only game for showers where the mom-to-be said no to the diapers. Write your own list so it fits the bars you have.
Printing and setup tips
- Print the guest sheet at “Actual size” or 100% on US Letter.
- Print one host answer key and keep it face down until the reveal.
- Set the diapers on a tray, not straight on a tablecloth: melted chocolate stains.
- Keep a roll of paper towels and a trash bag next to the tray for cleanup.
- If you prep the diapers before the party, keep them flat in a box in a cool spot so the chocolate stays where you put it.
FAQ
How many diapers should I use?
Six to ten. Fewer than six is over quickly; the guest sheet has 10 lines.
Do I have to melt the candy bars?
No. Squashing a bar with a knife at room temperature also works, and the bits of nuts or wafer stay easier to see.
Can I put the candy bar in the diaper and microwave the diaper?
We don’t recommend it. Melt the chocolate in a microwave-safe bowl and spread it in afterward.
Do guests have to taste it?
No. The look-and-sniff version works on its own, and nobody has to eat anything.
What’s a good prize?
Something small and useful: a gift card, a nice chocolate bar, a candle. You can find more ideas in our baby shower prizes guide.
Candy bar names in this guide are trademarks of their owners. Shower Playbook isn’t affiliated with any candy maker, Pampers or any brand named here.
Sources
- Pampers, “Guess the Candy Bar”: https://www.pampers.com/en-us/pregnancy/baby-shower/printable-baby-shower-games/guess-the-candy-bar
- Michele Meleen and Lori Soard, LoveToKnow, “Baby Shower Candy Bar Game” (updated February 10, 2025): https://www.lovetoknow.com/celebrations/parties/baby-shower-candy-bar-game
- The Emily Post Institute, “Party Game Ideas for Baby Showers”: https://emilypost.com/advice/party-game-ideas-for-baby-showers
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration, “Food Allergies: What You Need to Know”: https://www.fda.gov/food/buy-store-serve-safe-food/food-allergies-what-you-need-know
- Hershey’s, Mounds product page: https://m.hersheys.com/mounds.html
- Reddit, r/BabyBumps, “Baby shower games/activities that aren’t cringe?” (user opinions): https://www.reddit.com/r/BabyBumps/comments/1xex4vl/baby_shower_gamesactivities_that_arent_cringe/